The rotational and divergent components of atmospheric circulation on tidally locked planets

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences NAS 118:13 (2021) e2022705118-e2022705118

Authors:

Mark Hammond, Neil T Lewis

Abstract:

<jats:p>Tidally locked exoplanets likely host global atmospheric circulations with a superrotating equatorial jet, planetary-scale stationary waves, and thermally driven overturning circulation. In this work, we show that each of these features can be separated from the total circulation by using a Helmholtz decomposition, which splits the circulation into rotational (divergence-free) and divergent (vorticity-free) components. This technique is applied to the simulated circulation of a terrestrial planet and a gaseous hot Jupiter. For both planets, the rotational component comprises the equatorial jet and stationary waves, and the divergent component contains the overturning circulation. Separating out each component allows us to evaluate their spatial structure and relative contribution to the total flow. In contrast with previous work, we show that divergent velocities are not negligible when compared with rotational velocities and that divergent, overturning circulation takes the form of a single, roughly isotropic cell that ascends on the day side and descends on the night side. These conclusions are drawn for both the terrestrial case and the hot Jupiter. To illustrate the utility of the Helmholtz decomposition for studying atmospheric processes, we compute the contribution of each of the circulation components to heat transport from day side to night side. Surprisingly, we find that the divergent circulation dominates day–night heat transport in the terrestrial case and accounts for around half of the heat transport for the hot Jupiter. The relative contributions of the rotational and divergent components to day–night heat transport are likely sensitive to multiple planetary parameters and atmospheric processes and merit further study.</jats:p>

Toward More Realistic Simulation and Prediction of Dust Storms on Mars

Bulletin of the American Astronomical Society American Astronomical Society 53:4 (2021)

Authors:

Claire Newman, Tanguy Bertrand, Joseph Battalio, Mackenzie Day, Manuel De La Torre Ju谩rez, Meredith K Elrod, Francesca Esposito, Lori Fenton, Claus Gebhardt, Steven J Greybush, Scott D Guzewich, Henrik Kahanp盲盲, Melinda Kahre, 脰zg眉r Karatekin, Brian Jackson, Mathieu Lapotre, Christopher Lee, Stephen R Lewis, Ralph D Lorenz, Germ谩n Mart铆nez, Javier Martin-Torres, Michael A Mischna, Luca Montabone, Lynn Neakrase, Alexey Pankine, Jorge Pla-Garcia, Peter L Read, Isaac B Smith, Michael D Smith, Alejandro Soto, Aymeric Spiga, Christy Swann, Leslie Tamppari, Orkun Temel, Daniel Viudez Moreiras, Danika Wellington, Paulina Wolkenberg, Gerhard Wurm, Mar铆a-Paz Zorzano

Abstract:

While its primary objectives were to study the interior of Mars and its present day seismic activity, the InSight lander also carried several meteorological sensors (primarily needed to differentiate true seismic signals from those produced by wind or passing vortices, or as part of a heat flow experiment) as well as cameras which could be used to monitor atmospheric and surface changes [1-6]. Although power became increasingly limited due to dust build-up on the lander鈥檚 solar panels [7], InSight鈥檚 Pressure Sensor measured nearly continuously at up to 20Hz for ~1.25 Mars years, giving the highest frequency pressure dataset yet obtained on Mars [8,9]. The Temperature and Winds for InSight (TWINS) instrument consisted of two booms pointing in opposite directions (such that at least one sensor would measure winds from a given direction with minimal influence from lander hardware). Each boom measured air temperature and winds at 1Hz nearly continuously for over one Mars year [8,10]. The Heat Flow and Physical Properties Package (HP3) regularly measured the diurnal variation of surface temperature [11,12], while aeolian observations revealed that vortices rather than linear wind stress were associated with the majority of particle motion events [10,13]. We will provide an overview of InSight鈥檚 meteorological and aeolian datasets, and show how we are using them to validate the predictions of four global and four mesoscale atmospheric models of InSight鈥檚 landing site in Elysium Planitia. The models used include Aeolis Research鈥檚 multiscale MarsWRF model (run at global and mesoscales) [14,15], the Open University鈥檚 global Mars model (in the form of the OpenMars reanalysis dataset, produced via data assimilation) [16], the global Mars version of LMD鈥檚 Planetary Climate Model [17], LMD鈥檚 mesoscale Mars model [18], and the Belgian version of the MarsWRF global model [19]. This work goes beyond previous pre-landing multi-model intercomparison and prediction efforts [e.g., 14] by assessing the performance of models against data and attempting to understand the reasons for differences, with the dual goals of better understanding the causes of weather phenomena at InSight and of improving Mars atmospheric model predictions of the near-surface environment. This is vital not only for improving future landing site predictions (which are key to planning Entry-Descent-Landing and surface mission operations), including the expected dust clearing from solar panels [7,20], but also for Mars science in general, such as improving the prediction of near-surface wind and dust lifting globally in order to better simulate the martian dust cycle and dust storms [21]

Turbulent kinetic energy spectra and cascades in the polar atmosphere of Saturn

Copernicus Publications (2021)

Authors:

Peter L Read, Arrate Antu帽ano, Simon Cabanes, Greg Colyer, Teresa del Rio-Gaztelurrutia, Agustin S谩nchez-Lavega

Abstract:

The regions of Saturn鈥檚 cloud-covered atmosphere polewards of 60o latitude are dominated in each hemisphere near the cloud tops by an intense, cyclonic polar vortex surrounded by a strong, high latitude eastward zonal jet. In the north, this high latitude jet takes the form of a remarkably regular zonal wavenumber m=6 hexagonal pattern that has been present at least since the Voyager spacecraft encounters with Saturn in 1980-81, and probably much longer. The origin of this feature, and the absence of a similar feature in the south, has remained poorly understood since its discovery. In this work, we present some new analyses of horizontal wind measurements at Saturn鈥檚 cloud tops polewards of 60 degrees in both the northern and southern hemispheres, previously published by Antu帽ano et al. (2015) using images from the Cassini mission, in which we compute kinetic energy spectra and the transfer rates of kinetic energy (KE) and enstrophy between different scales. 2D KE spectra are consistent with a zonostrophic regime, with a steep听(~n-5) spectrum for the mean zonal flow (n is the total wavenumber) and a shallower Kolmogorov-like KE spectrum (~n-5/3)听for the residual (eddy) flow, much as previously found for Jupiter鈥檚 atmosphere (Galperin et al. 2014; Young & Read 2017). Three different methods are used to compute the energy and enstrophy transfers, (a) as latitude-dependent zonal spectral fluxes, (b) as latitude-dependent structure functions and (c) as spatially filtered energy fluxes. The results of all three methods are largely in agreement in indicating a direct (forward) enstrophy cascade across most scales, averaged across the whole domain, an inverse kinetic energy cascade to large scales and a weak direct KE cascade at the smallest scales. The pattern of transfers has a more complex dependence on latitude, however. But it is clear that the m=6 North Polar Hexagon (NPH) wave was transferring KE into its zonal jet at 78o N (planetographic) at a rate of 鈭E 鈮 1.8 x 10-4 W kg-1听at the time the Cassini images were acquired. This implies that the NPH was not maintained by a barotropic instability at this time, but may have been driven via a baroclinic instability or possibly from deep convection. Further implications of these results will be discussed.

References

Antu帽ano, A., T. del R铆o-Gaztelurrutia, A. S谩nchez-Lavega, and R. Hueso (2015), Dynamics of Saturn鈥檚 polar regions, J. Geophys. Res. Planets, 120, 155鈥176, doi:10.1002/2014JE004709.

Galperin, B., R. M.B. Young, S. Sukoriansky, N. Dikovskaya, P. L. Read, A.听J. Lancaster & D. Armstrong (2014) Cassini observations reveal a regime of zonostrophic macroturbulence on Jupiter, Icarus, 229, 295鈥320.doi: 10.1016/j.icarus.2013.08.030

Young, R. M. B. & Read, P. L. (2017) Forward and inverse kinetic energy cascades in Jupiter鈥檚 turbulent weather layer, Nature Phys., 13, 1135-1140. Doi:10.1038/NPHYS4227

Planetary and atmospheric properties leading to strong super-rotation in terrestrial atmospheres studied with a semi-grey GCM

Copernicus Publications (2021)

Authors:

Neil Lewis, Peter Read

Abstract:

Super-rotation is a phenomenon in atmospheric dynamics where the specific axial angular momentum of the wind (at some location) in an atmosphere exceeds that of the underlying planet at the equator. Hide's theorem states that in order for an atmosphere to super-rotate, non-axisymmetric disturbances (eddies) are required to induce transport of angular momentum up its local gradient. This raises a question as to the origin and nature of the disturbances that operate in super-rotating atmospheres to induce the required angular momentum transport.

The primary technique employed to investigate this question has involved numerically modelling super-rotating atmospheres, and diagnosing the processes that give rise to super-rotation in the simulations. These modelling efforts can be separated into one of two approaches. The first approach utilises 'realistic', tailor-made models of Solar System atmospheres where super-rotation is present (e.g., Venus and Titan) to investigate the specific processes responsible for generating super-rotation on each planet. The second approach takes simple, 'Earth-like' models, typically dry dynamical cores with radiative transfer represented using a Newtonian cooling approach, and explores the effect of varying a single (or occasionally multiple) planetary parameters (e.g., the planetary radius or rotation rate) on the atmospheric dynamics. Notably, studies of this flavour have shown that super-rotation may emerge 'spontaneously' on planets with slow rotation rate or small radius (relative to the Earth's; Venus and Titan have these characteristics). However, the strength of super-rotation obtained in simulations of this type is far weaker than that observed in Venus' or Titan's atmospheres, or in tailored numerical models of either planet.

In this work, our aim is to bridge the gap between these two modelling approaches. We will present results from a suite of simulations using an idealised general circulation model with a semi-grey representation of radiative transfer. Our experiments explore the effects of varying planetary size and rotation rate, atmospheric mass, and atmospheric absorption of shortwave radiation on the acceleration of super-rotation. A novel aspect of this work is that we vary multiple planetary properties away from their Earth-like 'defaults' in conjunction. This allows us to investigate how properties characteristic of the atmospheres of planets such as Venus and Titan combine to yield the strong super-rotation observed in their atmospheres (and realistic numerical models). We are also able to illustrate how features such as increased atmospheric mass and absorption of shortwave radiation modify the weakly super-rotating state obtained in simple, Earth-like models towards one more characteristic of Titan or Venus.

Hemispheric tectonics on super-Earth LHS 3844b

Astrophysical Journal Letters IOP Publishing 908:2 (2021) L48

Authors:

Tobias G Meier, Dan J Bower, Tim Lichtenberg, Paul J Tackley, Brice-Olivier Demory

Abstract:

The tectonic regime of rocky planets fundamentally influences their long-term evolution and cycling of volatiles between interior and atmosphere. Earth is the only known planet with active plate tectonics, but observations of exoplanets may deliver insights into the diversity of tectonic regimes beyond the solar system. Observations of the thermal phase curve of super-Earth LHS 3844b reveal a solid surface and lack of a substantial atmosphere, with a temperature contrast between the substellar and antistellar point of around 1000 K. Here, we use these constraints on the planet's surface to constrain the interior dynamics and tectonic regimes of LHS 3844b using numerical models of interior flow. We investigate the style of interior convection by assessing how upwellings and downwellings are organized and how tectonic regimes manifest. We discover three viable convective regimes with a mobile surface: (1) spatially uniform distribution of upwellings and downwellings, (2) prominent downwelling on the dayside and upwellings on the nightside, and (3) prominent downwelling on the nightside and upwellings on the dayside. Hemispheric tectonics is observed for regimes (2) and (3) as a direct consequence of the day-to-night temperature contrast. Such a tectonic mode is absent in the present-day solar system and has never been inferred from astrophysical observations of exoplanets. Our models offer distinct predictions for volcanism and outgassing linked to the tectonic regime, which may explain secondary features in phase curves and allow future observations to constrain the diversity of super-Earth interiors.