Assessing Robustness and Bias in 1D Retrievals of 3D Global Circulation Models at High Spectral Resolution: A WASP-76 b Simulation Case Study in Emission

The Astrophysical Journal American Astronomical Society 990:2 (2025) 106

Authors:

Lennart van Sluijs, Hayley Beltz, Isaac Malsky, Genevieve H Pereira, L Cinque, Emily Rauscher, Jayne Birkby

Abstract:

High-resolution spectroscopy (HRS) of exoplanet atmospheres has successfully detected many chemical species and is quickly moving toward detailed characterization of the chemical abundances and dynamics. HRS is highly sensitive to the line shape and position; thus, it can detect three-dimensional (3D) effects such as winds, rotation, and spatial variation of atmospheric conditions. At the same time, retrieval frameworks are increasingly deployed to constrain chemical abundances, pressure–temperature (P–T) structures, orbital parameters, and rotational broadening. To explore the multidimensional parameter space, we need computationally fast models, which are consequently mostly one-dimensional (1D). However, this approach risks introducing interpretation bias since the planet’s true nature is 3D. We investigate the robustness of this methodology at high spectral resolution by running 1D retrievals on simulated observations in emission within an observational framework using 3D global circulation models of the quintessential HJ WASP-76 b. We find that the retrieval broadly recovers conditions present in the atmosphere, but that the retrieved P–T and chemical profiles are not a homogeneous average of all spatial and phase-dependent information. Instead, they are most sensitive to spatial regions with large thermal gradients, which do not necessarily coincide with the strongest emitting regions. Our results further suggest that the choice of parameterization for the P–T and chemical profiles, as well as Doppler offsets among opacity sources, impact the retrieval results. These factors should be carefully considered in future retrieval analyses.

Plume Activity on Europa: Current Knowledge and Search Strategy for Europa Clipper

The Planetary Science Journal IOP Publishing 6:8 (2025) 182

Authors:

Lorenz Roth, Erin Leonard, Kelly Miller, Matt Hedman, Lynnae C Quick, Tracy M Becker, Shawn Brooks, Corey Cochrane, Ashley Gerard Davies, Carolyn M Ernst, Cyril Grima, Candice J Hansen, Carly Howett, Sean Hsu, Xianzhe Jia, Adrienn Luspay-Kuti, Margaret Kivelson, Fabian Klenner, Alfred McEwen, William B McKinnon, Robert T Pappalardo, Frank Postberg, Julie Rathbun, Kurt D Retherford

Abstract:

The presence of cryovolcanic activity in the form of geyser-like plumes at Jupiter’s moon Europa is a much-debated topic. As an active plume could allow direct sampling by a passing spacecraft of a potentially habitable interior environment, the detection and analysis of ongoing plume activity would be of the highest scientific value. In the past decade, several studies have interpreted different remote and in situ observations as providing evidence for large gaseous plumes at different locations on Europa. However, definitive proof is elusive, and visible imaging data taken during spacecraft flybys do not reveal clear indications of ongoing activity. After arrival at Jupiter in 2030, the NASA Europa Clipper spacecraft will systematically search for and constrain plume activity at Europa utilizing a variety of investigations and methods during, before, and after close flybys. Given the lack of a confirmed plume detection to date, the Europa Clipper science team has adopted a global plume search strategy, not focusing on any specific geographical area or any specific type of observation. This global search strategy assigns enhanced value to data obtained early in the mission, which allows time for further observations and characterization of any observed plume at later times. Here we describe the current state of knowledge on plume activity, the Europa Clipper search strategy, and the role of various instruments on the Europa Clipper payload in this search.

Lucy Mission Search Plans for Activity around Its Jovian Trojan Flyby Targets

The Planetary Science Journal IOP Publishing 6:7 (2025) 177

Authors:

S Alan Stern, Carly Howett, Neil Dello Russo, Harold A Weaver, James F Bell, Dennis Reuter, Amy Simon, Hannah Kaplan, Keith Noll, John Spencer, Simone Marchi, Hal Levison

Abstract:

Activity in small bodies, defined here as the episodic or continuous release of material, was long thought to be exclusively a behavior of comets, but it has since been discovered in some centaurs, main-belt asteroids, and near-Earth asteroids. To date, however, no activity has been discovered on Jovian trojan asteroids, the target of NASA’s Lucy Discovery Program mission. Although Lucy was originally conceived without studies of or searches for trojan activity, it was realized in 2016–2017 that the spacecraft and scientific payload aboard Lucy could provide unique and meaningful constraints or detections on activity in these trojans. Here we describe how the Lucy mission will search for such activity using (i) its terminal tracking navigation camera to search for wide-field coma scattered light, (ii) its Lucy Long Range Reconnaissance Imager narrow-angle camera to also search for scattered light from any coma or jets, and (iii) its Multispectral Visible Imaging Camera imager to search for CN emission (a common activity tracer species in comets). Sensitivity estimates for each of those measurements are discussed below.

A 3D model simulation of hydrogen chloride photochemistry on Mars: Comparison with satellite data

Astronomy & Astrophysics EDP Sciences 699 (2025) ARTN A362

Authors:

Benjamin Benne, Paul I Palmer, Benjamin M Taysum, Kevin S Olsen, Franck Lefevre

Abstract:

Context. Hydrogen chloride (HCl) was independently detected in the Martian atmosphere by the Nadir and Occultation for MArs Discovery (NOMAD) and Atmospheric Chemistry Suite (ACS) spectrometers aboard the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO). Photochemical models show that using gas-phase chemistry alone is insufficient to reproduce these data. Recent work has developed a heterogeneous chemical network within a 1D photochemistry model, guided by the seasonal variability in HCl. This variability includes detection almost exclusively during the dust season, a positive correlation with water vapour, and an anticorrelation with water ice. Aims. The aim of this work is to show that incorporating heterogeneous chlorine chemistry into a global 3D model of Martian photochemistry with conventional gas-phase chemistry can reproduce spatial and temporal changes in hydrogen chloride on Mars, as observed by instruments aboard the TGO. Methods. We incorporated this heterogeneous chlorine scheme into the Mars Planetary Climate Model (MPCM). After some refinements to the scheme, mainly associated with it being employed in a 3D model, we used it to model chlorine photochemistry during Mars Years (MYs) 34 and 35. These two years provide contrasting dust scenarios, with MY 34 featuring a global dust storm. We also examined correlations in the model results between HCl and other key atmospheric quantities, as well as production and loss processes, to understand the impact of different factors driving changes in HCl. Results. We find that the 3D model of Martian photochemistry using the proposed heterogeneous chemistry is consistent with the changes in HCl observed by ACS in MY 34 and MY 35, including detections and 70% of non-detections. For the remaining 30% of non-detections, model HCl is higher than the ACS detection limit due to biases associated with water vapour, dust, or water ice content at these locations. As with previous 1D model calculations, we find that heterogeneous chemistry is required to describe the loss of HCl, resulting in a lifetime of a few sols that is consistent with the observed seasonal variation in HCl. As a result of this proposed chemistry, modelled HCl is correlated with water vapour, airborne dust, and temperature, and anticorrelated with water ice. Our work shows that this chemical scheme enables the reproduction of aphelion detections in MY 35.

Assessing robustness and bias in 1D retrievals of 3D Global Circulation Models at high spectral resolution: a WASP-76 b simulation case study in emission

(2025)

Authors:

Lennart van Sluijs, Hayley Beltz, Isaac Malsky, Genevieve H Pereira, L Cinque, Emily Rauscher, Jayne Birkby